- Open Now
I can't speak for their breakfast sammie's but I can say I enjoyed my rainbow bagel with honey walnut cream cheese. I've always been amazed by rainbow bagels so I was happy to see Bagel Boys offered them. I placed an online order and arrived on time. I will say they should have a better system for pick up orders / orders placed in store because there was a long line to get in. I ended up calling and someone brought the bagel out for me. The bagel was huge! It was soft and chewy yet still firm on the outside. I wish there was more cream cheese on my bagel but all in all not bad. :)
Great bagel, muffin, fresh orange juice and coffee! Thank you ! The owner shared there may be a wait. It was worth the wait. We are not from the area- and appreciate the honesty. To those who leave a bad review because you have no patience - that should not be a reflection on this family business. The food is fresh and everyone here is working hard to make people happy.
Overall this bagel place is pretty good! I will admit I do not know what a NY bagel tastes like so cant compare it to that. I have been twice and havent experience the most of items mentioned for example, I haven't had to wait long or had an incorrect order. I do understand how space is an issue and what makes it worse in my opinion is how hot it is in there. I knocked a star because how expensive it is and the inconsistencies- I ordered the same item 2 weeks apart and there is a visual difference and less of each ingredient the second one is even missing an item that was on it before- the capers. My (picky) husband loves coffee and the bagel so thats a win in my book! All of the employees I have interacted with gave been very pleasant!
I was in the mood for something simple so I got an everything bagel with regular cream cheese. Really good bagel! Crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. They were out of the everything bagels so they told me there would be a short wait for one which was fine and clearly explained to me. I also got the breakfast potatoes which were surprisingly good with quite a bit of seasoning. Also got a traditional cappuccino which was also really good. I don't come to a bagel place expecting good coffee so I was pleasantly surprised by that. Service was also quite friendly and seemed genuinely helpful.
I got an everything bagel with turkey, tomato, and lettuce. When I got my order it had spinach on it and the bagel was so toasted it could be considered burnt. The bagel was also not cut and it was not given to me in a bag. Despite the fact that there were two customers in the store, when I ordered it, it took me 25 minutes to get my food. I could have driven all the way to Poppy Seeds, gotten my order, and driven home during the time it took me to get what should have been a three minute meal. Next time thats what Ill do.