Hawthorne's New York Pizza & Bar
- Open Now
First time coming here, heard great things. My order was late coming out. They forgot an entire caesar salad, my sandwich was not how I ordered it, my mozzarella sticks were cold & my pizza wasnt how I ordered it. I tipped well & when I got home I just couldnt t believe how messed up my order was. Im not one to take time to write a review, but I had to this time.
Pizza is perfect NY style and great value. Location is excellent, patio option really comes through towards sunset. Draft beers are a bit on the pricier side though.
Staff was great! Drinks were awesome! Order was incorrect. Offered to only remove the charge for extra topping.
Chris is great not sure if he was the manager or not but he carried himself so well and it reflects because the crew/staff act the same say. Food quality is good and bar staff and drinks are good as well.
Ordered online the Elizabeth Special full size(I think 18"?), and was able to pick it up in about 35 min. I can't truly speak to whether it is "Authentically New York", but the crust was thinner, and the slices were big enough to fold before gobbling them down, so I was sold. The pizza itself was pretty good. The toppings were flavorful, the crust was just the right amount of chewy and the cheese was, well, it was cheese. The first few bites seemed a bit salty, but after that my tongue either got used to it or it all evened out(and I didn't wake up the next day completely parched, so probably I just hot a salty spot). Would have rated 5 stars, but kinda expensive; total came to $28...which was decidedly un New Yorkish, where slices can be only a few dollars. So try it you like, but make sure you skip lunch so you can afford a full pie.