- Open Now
We were too full to get gelato the first time we came to Optimist Hall, so this time we made sure to save room. My favorite thing about this place is the variety of unique flavors. There are so many good options. They let us sample quite a few. We ended up getting a cup with 3 scoops: one cinnamon roll, one French toast, one brown butter crunch. They were all amazing. Cinnamon roll was my favorite, but it seems like you really can't go wrong here. They were very friendly. I'm excited to welcome another great dessert spot to town!
The caramel is delicious. I'll definitely go back :)
I've been there 3 times and 2 they were out of cones. That right there ruined the experience. I'm from Italy and I'd say it's ok for ice cream but not great gelato. Last time I tried salted caramel brownie and Nutella. The salted caramel brownie was very watery. Nutella was good. My daughter had strawberry and it wasn't too sweet, which is a good thing
First time having gelato. (Dont judge me). Loved this spot(location). Loved the gelato!! This is going to be an AWESOME spring/summer hangout.
Toasted coconut ice cream and lemon basil slush