Benny Pennello's
M B
3/17/2022 stopped here for a slice for lunch. I ordered one slice of the sausage pizza which was plenty to eat for one person! I also ordered a ginger ale in can drink ($1). The slices are huge and they taste great!!! Im not a pizza connoisseur but this is pretty good pizza in my opinion. I would recommend stopping here for lunch or dinner. $8.05 including tip!
Nicodemous
Randomly found this place searching on Google maps after a night on the town in Queen City. I saw It had a ton of reviews and decided to give it a try. The Carolina game had just finished and the line was out the door, I almost drove off, but I'm sure glad I didn't. Had a blast sitting in line trash talking waiting for my chance at a slice of pizza (seeing as near closing time they stop selling whole pizzas and you have to come buy slices). The atmosphere was nice and so was the customer service (quick in and quick out). And the pizza was amazing for the price and the slices were HUGE, they have to give you each slice on two paper plates and if you order to go three slices have to be put in a large pizza box!
Ronnie Lee
Not a great experience. Ordered 3 cheese slices and received slices that looked like someone picked the pepperoni off the pizza to make it appear as if they were cheese slices. Oddly 2 pepperonis were left on pizza. I called and spoke to Aiden about the matter. He didnt seem to care. The whole experience turned me off. Bird Pizzeria is my new pizza spot. Their pizza is so much better than Bennys.
Steve O'Reilly
One of the largest pizzas I've ever seen! The slice comes on 2 paper plates! Although originally from VA. the pizza is a classic NY slice. Thin, foldable and just the right blend of cheese and sauce. Atmosphere is rustic and all paper and plastic utensils. Worth a stop and follow up with a brew at Heist brewery which is right next door.
Robert Savage
Id give this place 10 stars if I could. Pizza quality is very subjective, but for my family this one is IT. Best pizza, staff is always awesome, great beer selection, decently priced. Well worth the drive. Please, please open one in Rock Hill!
